Matthews Logo

Navigation Menu

A Bifurcated Market

A Bifurcated Market featured image

The net lease market has become increasingly bifurcated over the last several years as interest rates rose. With treasuries climbing again, those divisions are likely to become even more defined.

By Chad Kurz, Executive Vice President | October 2026

When an earthquake strikes, it sends a sudden shock through Earth’s surface, often followed by aftershocks as the crust continues to adjust to the shifts in stress caused by the initial rupture. While aftershocks are typically smaller and cause less damage, the damage they cause is usually to structures that were weakened by the original earthquake.

In the net lease market, 2022 was the earthquake. The Fed raised its benchmark rate, and the 10-year Treasury yield climbed roughly 250 basis points in a single year. The recent run-up in the 10-year Treasury, about 100 basis points since the beginning of the year, is merely an aftershock for the net lease market. The 10-year Treasury peaked in September 2026 when it topped 5%, the highest level since 2007. Despite the initial shock, the net lease market proved resilient, with continued demand from investors trading out of management-intensive properties and into passive investments.

For many real estate professionals, 2022 was likely the first time in their careers that they experienced a rise in interest rates; rates had more or less continued to decrease from the early 1980s through 2021. At the time, I wrote an article titled “Traffic Jam” predicting that market conditions would drastically slow down. That was followed by an article titled “Unrealized Losses” on the five stages of grief, which argued that in order for the market to move on, sellers had to go through denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and finally acceptance of new market conditions. By 2025, most sellers and buyers seemed to accept the new market conditions and activity did increase to what felt like a new normal. The recent aftershock to the net lease market could expose those owners whose “foundation and structure” appeared solid but, in reality, were severely damaged by the initial earthquake. The real damage has likely already occurred, but whether further increases in interest rates will trigger additional aftershocks remains uncertain.

“In the net lease market, 2022 was the earthquake.”

Five Divides

01 Core vs. Credit

Cap rates for core assets, in strong locations and with replaceable rent, have remained aggressive. For many of these assets, cap rates are only about 25–50 basis points higher today than they were in 2021, when interest rates were substantially lower. At the same time, traditional credit assets, where a buyer is largely purchasing the lease rather than the underlying real estate, have seen cap rates move by as much as 150 to 200 basis points. These assets are typically more challenging to re-tenant at similar rents and are often located in less desirable locations. The difference is largely driven by buyer preference: purchasing a strong cash-flowing asset versus purchasing a generational asset. The one thing all deals have in common, though, is that they are still trading at historically low spreads to the 10-year Treasury, and the recent run-up has tightened those spreads further.

02 Debt vs. No Debt

Even at the more aggressive cap rates of 2021, an owner purchasing with leverage could typically generate a higher return on equity than an all-cash buyer. This was true for the majority of the 21st century, and many buyers took advantage of this. When they locked in long-term debt, it provided security from sudden rises in interest rates. Perhaps even more important, paying down a larger percentage of the loan before a required refinance provided additional security. Owners with no debt had the ultimate security, albeit at a lower return. The distress we saw in the last few years was largely due to highly leveraged loans that came due or floating-rate debt. It’s unlikely we will see similar distress in the market from the recent increase in rates compared to previous years. However, those who put long-term fixed debt on properties are now much closer to needing to refinance at potentially significantly higher interest rates.

03 High Price vs. Low Price

As mentioned above, buyers could typically increase returns through leverage, which kept demand high. Today, with borrowing costs high and the spread between borrowing costs and cap rates historically narrow, leverage means more risk and a lower return. Rising interest rates also generally put upward pressure on cap rates across product types, although the magnitude varies by product type. As a result, many exchange buyers are selling their properties for prices similar to what they would have sold for in 2021, while new construction prices for net lease assets have increased significantly. This creates an imbalance for exchange buyers moving into net lease, as higher construction costs and the economics required to justify development equate to higher purchase prices. Finally, an investor who can purchase a $10 million asset can also purchase a $2 million asset, but not vice versa. This has caused cap rate expansion for higher-priced assets.

04 Retail Owners vs. Non-Retail Owners

A significant source of demand for net lease assets today is exchange buyers selling non-retail assets and purchasing passive net lease assets. The rise in cap rates for their assets does not deter their motivation to sell, as their primary goal is to move into passive investments as they age out of management-intensive properties. Retail owners do not share that motivation, since they already own passive investments. For those with existing financing on a retail asset, selling and buying another asset would mean taking on more risk for a lower return, which doesn’t make sense. Thus, 1031 exchange buyers continue to move out of management-intensive properties and into passive net lease investments. That could shift as retail owners’ existing financing comes due. Some may be pushed to sell, adding inventory and putting pressure on pricing.

05 Institutional Buyer vs. Non-Institutional Buyer

As interest rates increase or stock prices fall, institutional buyers require a higher yield on properties they purchase. For many product types, these institutional groups represent a majority of the buyer pool. Much like the ocean’s tide rising or falling due to the gravitational pull from the moon, certain retailers’ cap rates rise or fall due to the gravitational pull of institutional buyers. If institutional capital moves its target cap rate from 6.50% to 7.00% for a certain retailer, limited demand from other buyers can make it difficult to maintain previous pricing levels, pushing cap rates higher. While institutional groups play an important role in the overall net lease market, specific retailers benefit more from their demand than others.

“A weatherman doesn’t make the weather, and a broker doesn’t control interest rates.”

Our Approach

How are we responding?

A weatherman doesn’t make the weather, and a broker doesn’t control interest rates. I don’t know about you, but when there is a cold front or a heatwave, I adjust my outfits and behaviors to adapt to the environment. As a brokerage, we have adapted to the changing market conditions, adjusting our strategy to better position our clients for success.

About five years ago when we saw the shift in interest rates, we made a conscious effort to focus on buyers entering the net lease market as demand started dropping. With less demand, the logical thing was to find buyers who could purchase the properties we had listed for the clients that trusted us with an assignment. While this sounds logical, it is not typical among brokers. Earlier in my career, the emphasis was on listing-side business and controlling the inventory rather than spending time identifying buyers. However, what good is it to have inventory if we don’t have buyers to purchase those deals?

This was a fundamental shift in our business and something very few brokers are currently doing. This shift has generated meaningful results for our clients. We have sourced and represented more than $250 million in exchange buyers who otherwise wouldn’t have entered the market. They purchased countless deals through our developer relationships that otherwise would not have occurred. Some of our greatest satisfaction comes from finding a buyer for a previously listed deal that other brokers couldn’t find.

This past year, we doubled down on this approach. For the first time in my career, my mentee agents focused exclusively on identifying exchange buyers. This meant calling, emailing, texting, and campaigning to sellers of multifamily, industrial, self-storage, land, and even retail properties to put our net lease inventory in front of them while simultaneously explaining the benefits of net lease. It’s challenging to have the same conversation with owners who know little about net lease, but rewarding when we uncover a great buyer for one of our deals, one who wasn’t previously in the market. The thought process was, and continues to be: if natural demand has declined, we have to create demand artificially through new processes.

As a company, we have not only worked harder, but smarter. When I was at previous large national brokerage companies before founding Matthews™, I worked off my own individual database and did not share contact information with other brokers. The multifamily agent sitting across from me had a completely different database, as did the industrial agent and, I assume, every other agent at the company. Even when we started as a retail-only company, we only had retail owners in our database. It simply didn’t make sense to spend years building a database of multifamily owners for a product type we didn’t sell, not to mention the management and upkeep that database would require. However, since our company started after the rise of the internet, we were able to use one centralized database. As we expanded into different product types, agents in multifamily, industrial, self-storage, and land researched owners and added them to the same database. Now, with over 1,000 agents across all product types, we benefit from the ability to market a net lease property to owners of other asset classes. In today’s market, these are typically the best buyers. I am unaware of any other company that has this capability, as most large brokerage companies have individual databases and most retail-only companies have retail-only databases.

We’re all in this together. I am rooting for rates to come down; my life would be easier and most people in real estate would be better off. I am concerned for my kids about the amount of debt we have as a country and what that future might look like if trends continue. However, I recognize there are things I control and things I don’t, and interest rates are not something I control. The only thing we can do is adapt to the changing market and try to put ourselves and our clients in the best position.

Chad Kurz
EVP & Managing Director
(562) 480-2937
chad.kurz@matthews.com
License No. 01911198 (CA)

matthews.com

Disclaimer: This information has been produced by Matthews™ solely for information purposes and the information contained has been obtained from public sources believed to be reliable. While we do not doubt their accuracy, we have not verified such information. No guarantee, warranty or representation, expressed or implied, is made as to the accuracy or completeness of any information contained and Matthews™ shall not be liable to any reader or third party in any way. This information is not intended to be a complete description of the markets or developments to which it refers. All rights to the material are reserved and cannot be reproduced without prior written consent of Matthews™.

Similar Articles

What El Niño Could Mean for Midwest Net Lease Properties This Winter

Read More
A Bifurcated Market image

A Bifurcated Market

Read More
How AI is Reshaping Central Texas Industrial image

How AI is Reshaping Central Texas Industrial

Read More
New York City, NY Industrial Market Report Q3 2026 image

New York City, NY Industrial Market Report Q3 2026

Read More