Matthews Logo

Navigation Menu

40-42 First Street, Ilion, NY, 14489

Kinney Pharmacy & Dunkin’

$3,109,333

Key Information

Cap Rate
7.5%
$ per SF
$232
Tot. SF
13,350
Lot Size
1.55 Acres
Units
2
Year Built
2006
Term Remaining
± 6.39 Years
Type
Retail
NOI
$233,201

Highlights

• Diversified Two-Tenant Income — The property is leased to Kinney Drugs and Dunkin’, diversifying income across pharmacy and quick-service restaurant uses. The two-tenant structure reduces reliance on a single operator while combining an established regional pharmacy with a nationally recognized restaurant brand.
• Attractive 7.50% Going-In Yield — Offered at $3,109,333, the property provides a 7.50% cap rate with approximately 6.4 years of weighted-average lease term remaining, providing investors with attractive current yield and visibility into future cash flow.
• Immediate Contractual Rent Growth — Annual base rent increases from approximately $226,000 to $233,201 in November 2026 through Dunkin’s scheduled rent increase. The contractual increase provides near-term income growth without relying on lease renewal, market rent growth, or additional capital investment.
• Low-Maintenance NN Structure — Both tenants are responsible for taxes, insurance, and CAM, with landlord responsibilities primarily limited to the roof and structure. The NN structure reduces day-to-day ownership obligations and provides investors with a more passive income stream.
• 50,000+ Resident Trade Area — More than 50,000 residents live within 10 miles of the property, with average household income exceeding $81,000. Ilion is positioned along the I-90 corridor with Utica approximately 20 minutes away, providing access to a larger regional employment and consumer base.
• Recent Lease Renewals — Both Dunkin’ and Kinney Drugs recently exercised renewal options, demonstrating continued commitment to the location and reinforcing the long-term stability of the tenant mix.
• Largest Private Dunkin’ Franchisee — Cafua Management Company operates 200+ Dunkin’ locations across seven states, making it the largest private Dunkin’ franchisee in the U.S. and providing experienced, established operations behind the lease.

Photos

Location

Agents

Broker of Record

Cory Rosenthal

License # 10311210106, 10991237833 (NY)
Matthews Real Estate Investment Services, Inc
575 5th Ave., Ste 2810 New York, NY 10017