Matthews Logo

Navigation Menu

412 Park Avenue, Kinston, NC, 28501

Self Storage Brothers

$3,000,000

Key Information

Cap Rate
4.12%
Proforma Cap
9.71%
$ per SF
$75
Lot Size
5.6 Acres
Units
291
Year Built
1980 | 2024
Type
Self Storage
Occupancy
44%
NOI
$123,538
Leasable Area
39,703

Highlights

• Recently converted, majority climate-controlled self-storage facility
Very attractive basis at $75 per rentable square foot
• Three commercial warehouse spaces all currently leased to small businesses, generating $96k per year
Projected 5-Year Levered IRR north of 21%. Yield-on-Cost projected north of 9.6% in Year 4 and 10.64% Year 4 Cap Rate
• Solid YTD leasing activity despite spending minimal advertising dollars each month
Airbus took direct ownership of the 500,000 SF Kinston aerostructures plant in December 2025 and has since doubled headcount to approximately 1,000 employees
Fleet Readiness Center East is building a $450–500M, 700,000+ SF C-130/HH-60W Navy Depot maintenance complex at the Global TransPark, adding approximately 450 jobs
The region announced 738 jobs and $262M in investment in 2025, including Electrolux ($23.7M, 74 jobs) and Cardon Rehabilitation’s first U.S. plant, both located in Kinston.
• The 2,500-acre Global TransPark, home to North Carolina’s longest runway, drives $781M in annual output, approximately 3,000 jobs, and $66K average wages versus $46K countywide.
• MCAS Cherry Point (45 mi) and Seymour Johnson AFB (30 mi) form a 15,000-person military demand base that drives recurring PCS-cycle storage demand; Seymour Johnson was named the F-15EX recipient in August 2026.
• The market has zero REIT competition and zero new supply in the last two years. There are also no institutional operators within 10-miles of the site.At 44,325 SF, the subject is the largest available asset in the market, trailing only Brooks Mini Storage, whose facilities also hold the #2 and #3 positions.
• Downtown Kinston has attracted $150M+ in private investment, anchored by Mother Earth Brewing, Chef & the Farmer, and the O’Neil Hotel, and is now advancing a city-approved master plan and riverwalk.

Photos

Location

Agents

Broker of Record

Gerard Hamas

License # 362768, C42113 (NC)
Matthews of North Carolina, LLC
307 W. Tremont Ave., Ste 200, Charlotte, NC 28203