Matthews Logo

Navigation Menu

1322 Mahan Drive, Tallahassee, FL, 32308

Mahan Plaza

$7,974,515

Key Information

Cap Rate
7.5%
$ per SF
$281
Tot. SF
28,350
Lot Size
3.86 Acres
Units
18
Year Built
1988
Type
Shopping Centers
NOI
$598,089

Highlights

• Fully Occupied Asset: Mahan Plaza features 28,350 SF across 18 tenants with 100% occupancy, providing investors with immediate, in-place cash flow and no existing vacancy to lease up.
• Stable NNN Lease Structures: The asset currently has all 18 tenants operating under NNN leases, resulting in limited ongoing management and expense exposure.
• Diversified Neighborhood Tenant Mix: The property features a diverse mix of restaurant, medical, pharmacy, personal service and neighborhood-oriented tenants, reducing exposure to any single in-line tenant.
• Near-Term Rental Upside: Several leases expire within the next 12–36 months, providing opportunities to increase rents upon renewal. With four tenants currently paying $15/SF or less, these renewals offer meaningful potential for income growth.
• Two Freestanding Drive-Thru Buildings: In addition to its 16 in-line suites, the property features two freestanding drive-thru buildings occupied by Red Owl and Hip Hop Fish & Chicken, adding a highly sought-after real estate component to the overall investment. Additionally, Hip Hop Fish & Chicken currently pays just $29.53 PSF, well below market rents for drive-thru space, presenting investors with a compelling opportunity to increase rental income and create additional value.
• Excellent Access & Strategic Connectivity: The property benefits from dual access along E Mahan Drive (24,500 VPD) and N Magnolia Drive (24,500 VPD), providing convenient ingress and egress. E Mahan Drive serves as a major east-west thoroughfare connecting commuters to Interstate 10, supporting strong accessibility and consumer exposure.
• Limited New Supply: With very few development projects in NE Tallahassee, retail supply remains limited, protecting the center from new competition.
• Affluent, Dense & Educated Trade Area: Over 180,000 residents live within five miles, with average household income exceeding $124,000 within one mile. Approximately 45% of Tallahassee residents hold a bachelor’s degree, supporting a strong and established consumer base.
• Proximity to Florida State University: Located just ±2 miles from Florida State University Campus, home to over ±45,000 students, the property benefits from a substantial student population, consistent consumer traffic, and year-round demand for dining, retail, and service-oriented businesses.
• Strong Retail Synergy: Located within about a mile of Governor’s Square Mall, Macy’s, Ross, and Bealls, and near Tallahassee Memorial Hospital, placing the center in one of Tallahassee’s most established retail and medical corridors.

Photos

Location

Agents

Broker of Record

Kyle Matthews

License # BK3554632, CQ1066435 (FL)
Matthews Real Estate Investment Services, Inc
1600 West End Ave, Ste. 1500 Nashville, TN 37203